Saturday, July 21, 2007

Bad Justice 101

Exhibit A For Taping

July 20, 2007 Hartford Courant

One of the state's [Connecticut] most troubling criminal convictions in decades was back in court this week, as supporters of Richard A. Lapointe again attempted to gain a new trial. They believe he didn't commit the crime for which he has spent the last 18 years in prison. The habeas petition on Mr. Lapointe's behalf was brought in Rockville Superior Court by lawyers for Centurion Ministries, a New Jersey-based group that specializes in reversing wrongful convictions.

Without presuming his guilt or innocence, we believe there remain serious questions about the fairness of Mr. Lapointe's conviction. At the very least, the case argues for taping confessions. A meek, mentally handicapped man with no history of violence, Mr. Lapointe was convicted of the brutal rape and murder of his wife's 87-year-old grandmother in Manchester in 1987.

The case went unsolved for two years. Then on July 4, 1989, Manchester police invited Mr. Lapointe to the station and kept him there for almost 10 hours. He had no lawyer, and the interrogations weren't recorded. Mr. Lapointe signed three confessions.

Two were patently absurd - in one he confessed but said he didn't remember committing the crime - and a third, more detailed, confession was inconsistent on several points with forensic evidence and expert testimony, a Courant investigation found, and contained details almost certainly fed to him by police.

Would someone confess to a crime he didn't commit? Researches have found that it happens fairly often. Exhaustion, isolation and duress can distort reality. Experts such as Richard Ofshe of the University of California have documented hundreds of cases in which police have sweated confessions out of people later proved innocent. A handicapped person such as Mr. Lapointe, deferential to authority figures all his life, would be particularly vulnerable.

If his confessions had been videotaped, the jury could have gotten a sense of whether Mr. Lapointe was being coerced, was tired, was succumbing to the power of suggestion. Or not. Taped confessions also protect the police in many cases.

A bill in the General Assembly earlier this year would have set up pilot taping programs in Connecticut. It had the support of the chief state's attorney and the police chiefs association. But the legislature chose not to fund the measure - for equipment, training and standards - and so there is no program. There should be.

More articles

Copyright © 2007, The Hartford Courant

* * * *
* * * *

Lawyers have a feeding frenzy in Divorce Cases

Tauck V. Tauck: No End In Sight

Nancy Tauck

More on the above story [click here]

Wednesday, July 4, 2007

Soldiers and Civilians in War Zones

My Odyssey into the abyss of temporary homelessness and walking in the moonscape which was the devastation of coastal Mississippi and the New Orleans area of Louisiana made me often think of the conditions endured by America's fighting men and women, and the plight of the residents of war zones.

All people feel, care about their children, and want better for themselves and their communities. We bleed, we suffer, and we wear our wounds inside and out. Americans and citizens of the world should not be labeled the same as the extremists in their midst, and should not also be subject of the sociopaths of the worldwide police with their HQ in DC.
-Steven G. Erickson

This blogger's email:

Should police officers get now punishment for paying a hit man $10,000 to kill a citizen that lodged a police misconduct complaint against them? [click here for more]

[click here] for a list of all my YouTube videos

It wasn't a natural disaster that made me lose these houses, it was Connecticut Judicial, Prosecutorial, Official, Attorney, and Police Misconduct:

This blog accepts anonymous comments. To share this post with a friend, click on white envelope below